Hm, let's switch the labels and see what we get: "This is a classic antisemitic tactic of accusing your opponent of the very thing you are accused of."

Well, looks like it fits you at least as well as it fits the OP! And of course if you're accusing others of what you're guilty of, then it's your misinformation and falsehood, and we can discount what you say.

Now, maybe all you wanted to do was display your tribal allegiance and remind others in your tribe that tribe comes first, and deploy your rationalizations to make sure you don't waver. In that case--sure, yes, your answer does that.

But as something worthy of consideration by anyone thoughtful (regardless of their view of the conflict), it falls rather short.